Debunking QSR Minimal Wage BS: A Comply with Up


 

@TBPInvictus right here

A number of days in the past, Barry and I detailed how unscrupulous unhealthy actors had taken Not Seasonally Adjusted knowledge to falsely declare that California’s new $20/hour minimal wage had price the state nearly 10,000 quick-serve restaurant (QSR) jobs.

I wrote:

It seems to me that the Journal bought that quantity from BLS. Nevertheless, BLS solely affords the collection with out seasonal adjustment; this makes a really significant distinction.

Barry added:

There are two unhealthy gamers right here: The partisans who know they’re abusing the information, and the naive journos being taken benefit of whose editors are too innumerate to know even primary modeling points like seasonal changes.

Greatest practices when utilizing knowledge with a excessive diploma of seasonality is to make use of 12 months-over-12 months foundation (NSA) to your comparability. This removes the seasonality issue.

Pulitzer Prize successful LA Instances columnist Michael Hiltzik picked up on the difficulty, and did a masterful job explaining the complexities in layman’s phrases. His headline is basic:

The fast-food trade claims the California minimal wage regulation is costing jobs. Its numbers are faux.

Theheart of the column is the acknowledgment and recantation from one of many key sources of the misinformation, Professor Lee Ohanian. Ohanian wrote to Hiltzik:

Ohanian acknowledged by electronic mail that “if the information are usually not seasonally adjusted, then no conclusions could be drawn from these knowledge concerning AB 1228,” the minimal wage regulation.

Barry provides:

Two issues so as to add to this dialogue:

It’s one more reminder that traders should all the time be on guard for nonsensical claims from partisans who’ve zero concern to your portfolio. They’re enjoying a distinct recreation, and you might be collateral injury.

And second, all the time recall what Joan Robinson taught us so way back:

“The aim of learning economics is to not purchase a set of ready-made solutions to financial questions, however to learn to keep away from being deceived by economists.”

 

 

Supply:
The fast-food trade claims the California minimal wage regulation is costing jobs. Its numbers are faux.
by Michael Hiltzik
L.A. Instances, June 12, 2024

Free mirror: Yahoo

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrint Friendly, PDF & Email

Recent Articles

Related Stories

Leave A Reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here